- Open Access
A simplified method for power-law modelling of metabolic pathways from time-course data and steady-state flux profiles
- Tomoya Kitayama†1,
- Ayako Kinoshita†1,
- Masahiro Sugimoto1, 2,
- Yoichi Nakayama1, 3Email author and
- Masaru Tomita1
© Kitayama et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2006
- Received: 08 January 2006
- Accepted: 17 July 2006
- Published: 17 July 2006
In order to improve understanding of metabolic systems there have been attempts to construct S-system models from time courses. Conventionally, non-linear curve-fitting algorithms have been used for modelling, because of the non-linear properties of parameter estimation from time series. However, the huge iterative calculations required have hindered the development of large-scale metabolic pathway models. To solve this problem we propose a novel method involving power-law modelling of metabolic pathways from the Jacobian of the targeted system and the steady-state flux profiles by linearization of S-systems.
The results of two case studies modelling a straight and a branched pathway, respectively, showed that our method reduced the number of unknown parameters needing to be estimated. The time-courses simulated by conventional kinetic models and those described by our method behaved similarly under a wide range of perturbations of metabolite concentrations.
The proposed method reduces calculation complexity and facilitates the construction of large-scale S-system models of metabolic pathways, realizing a practical application of reverse engineering of dynamic simulation models from the Jacobian of the targeted system and steady-state flux profiles.
- Experimental Noise
- Mean Relative Error
- Generalize Mass Action
- Logarithmic Gain
- Perturbation Range
Systematic modelling has emerged as a powerful tool for understanding the mathematical properties of metabolic systems. The rapid development of metabolic measurement techniques has driven advances in modelling, especially using data on the effects of perturbations of metabolite concentrations, which contain valuable information about metabolic pathway structure and regulation . A power-law approximation for representing enzyme-catalyzed reactions, known as Biochemical Systems Theory, is an effective approach for understanding metabolic systems [2, 3]. Generalized Mass Action (GMA) and S-systems [4, 5], which are often used as power-law modelling approaches, have wide representational spaces that permit adequate expression of enzyme kinetics  in spite of their simple fixed forms. Moreover since S-system forms have a smaller number of parameters than GMA forms, the S-system is an appropriate modelling framework. The derivation of an S-system model from given experimental data is a powerful tool not only for understanding non-linear properties but also for determining the regulatory structure of the system [7, 8].
S-system modelling from time-course data is often difficult due to its non-linear properties. Non-linear-fitting algorithms, such as genetic algorithms or artificial neural networks, have been used to resolve this problem [9–14]. Although these methods can be applied to metabolic pathways, massive computing power is required in the case of targeted models involving a number of closely-connected, underspecified parameters . Moreover, the wider the range of targeted metabolic pathways, the more likely is the occurrence of local minima due to the expansion of the parameter search space. The network-structures-segmentation method can reduce the total parameter search range in genetic network modelling  but it is difficult to apply this to metabolic pathways because of the close relationships between reversible reactions and because of allosteric regulation. Diaz-Sierra and Fairén have proposed an approach, based on the steady-state assumption, that allows the construction of S-system models from a Jacobian matrix of the system . Since the Jacobian constrains the search range of underspecified parameters at the optimization stage, these authors' method allows efficient parameter estimation. However, the problem of an excess number of parameters requiring estimation remains unsolved.
We present an approach to power-law modelling of metabolic pathways from the Jacobian of the targeted system and steady-state flux profiles with linearization of the S-system. This reduces the number of underspecified parameters. Two numerical experiments show that the S-system model generated by this method describes similar dynamic behaviour to that indicated by conventional kinetic models.
Retrieving the Jacobian from time-course data
As a first step, the Jacobian must be obtained from metabolic time-course data. In this section, we summarize the method of Sorribas et al , which we use in this work.
In biochemical systems, the Jacobian can be defined as:
where J is the Jacobian matrix, and δX represents a small perturbation and contains the concentration Xi as its elements. The elements of the Jacobian can be obtained from perturbed time-courses using linear least-squares fitting [17, 18]. This method is based on the fact that transients yield linear responses to small perturbations under steady-state conditions . The mathematical basis for this is that the linear representation constitutes the first-order term of a Taylor series expansion, which is sufficiently accurate in this situation.
Determination of the kinetic orders of the S-system
The S-system is a power-law representation constructed of two terms: the production rate and the degradation rate:
where αi and βi are rate constants, gij and hij are kinetic orders, and xi represents the concentration of a compound.
In steady state conditions, it can be expressed simply as:
Flux = V+ = V - (3)
where Flux is the sum of the steady-state fluxes into xi, and V+ and V- are production and consumption terms, respectively.
In steady state conditions, the production term and the consumption term in Eq.(2) can therefore be represented as:
where xj,0 represents the steady-state concentration of xj.
Consequently αi and βi yield:
Defining Xi as:
the Jacobian of Eq. (2) can be represented as:
Once Jacobian Jij, xj,0, and Flux are given, Eq. (10) is a constraint for the determination of the kinetic orders gij and hij. Savageau has described the linearization of S-system as an "F-factor" for stability analysis . We use this representation to estimate parameter values.
In most cases gij and/or hij are available from the structure of the metabolic pathway; however, in the absence of known kinetic orders, parameter estimates are needed to determine them. In such cases Eq. (10) is adopted as limiting the parameter search range.
Case study 1: a linear biochemical pathway
In this case, all parameters of the S-system model were determined, without the need for estimation. The biochemical model could be converted into the following S-system form.
Since X1 is an independent variable, it was omitted from the listed rate equations.
The following constraints were provided from the pathway structure: h22 = g32, h23 = g33, h33 = h43 = g53, h34 = h44 = g54, h54 = g44, h55 = g45, β2 = α3, β3 = β4 = α5, and α4 = β5. The steady-state concentrations were: X1,0 = 0.50 mM (fixed value), X2,0 = 0.146 mM, X3,0 = 0.007 mM, X4,0 = 0.817 mM, and X5,0 = 0.243 mM. The steady-state fluxes were: V1 = V2 = V3 = V4 = 0.081 mM/min. The Jacobian was:
Our method was able to generate the S-system model of the linear pathway from the steady-state metabolite concentrations, the steady-state fluxes, and its Jacobian. For example, g21 and g32 were determined by:
Because h22 is equal to g32,
In this modelling process, all the parameters were determined by simple calculations of this kind. The resulting S-system model was:
Case study 2: A branched biochemical pathway
The branched biochemical pathway shown in Figure 2 was tested in the second example. This pathway has the typical features of a biochemical pathway: branching, feedback regulation, and product inhibition (see Appendix 2). X3 is the inhibitor of both V3 and V4.
The following constraint was provided by the pathway structure: h11 = g21. Steady-state concentrations were: X1,0 = 0.067, X2,0 = 0.049, X3,0 = 0.081, X4,0 = 0.041, and steady-state fluxes were: V1 = V2 = 0.1, V3 = V5 = 0.043, and V4 = V6 = 0.057. The Jacobian was:
More than half of the parameters were obtained by simple calculations using the steady-state concentrations, the steady-state fluxes, and the Jacobian. The following four parameters could not be determined: α3, g33, β3, and h33. For example, h11 is a parameter which could be determined by:
Because g33 is a parameter that could not be determined by a calculation, an estimate provided by some constraint was needed. As α3, h33, and β3 could be treated as dependent parameters, once g33 was obtained all four parameters were determined:
Moreover, the search range of g33 could be limited by the definition that h33 has a positive value since X3 is the substrate of the reaction V3. The search range of g33 was set from 0 to -0.95. When the number of underspecified parameters was one whose search range was limited, a linear-fitting algorithm could be used to fit the time-course data in the original kinetic model. In this modelling, g33 was determined by a linear optimization method. Consequently, the following S-system model was generated:
The parameters of the S-system model in case study 2
Determined or Estimated
determined from g33
determined from g33
determined from g33
Comparing transient dynamic responses after perturbation
To evaluate the versatility of this method, the transient dynamics of the S-system model in response to various perturbations were compared with those of the original Michaelis-Menten model, by calculating the mean relative errors (MRE):
Power-law modelling from time-course data of metabolite concentrations often requires parameter estimates that depend on the size of the target metabolic network. Especially when developing a large-scale metabolic model, this requires problem-specific simplifications. Our method can reduce the number of underspecified parameters by using steady-state flux profiles and the Jacobian of the targeted system derived from time courses of metabolites, and is thus suitable for large-scale power-law modelling. To validate our methods we used two existing biochemical pathway models, the straight and branched pathway models, described by dynamic equations. In the S-system, modelling of a linear metabolic pathway with 12 parameters (case study 1), our method determines all parameters accurately, whereas the method developed by Diaz-Sierra and Fairén  leaves at least four parameters underspecified that include error correction parameters. In the case of the branched metabolic pathway with 16 parameters (case study 2), our method determines all but one parameter, whereas the method of Diaz-Sierra and Fairén has 12 underspecified parameters that include error correction parameters. The case studies demonstrate that our method of developing S-system models from time series can reduce the number of underspecified parameters more efficiently than the previously reported method . Furthermore, the perturbation response experiments show that the models created by our method can reproduce dynamics similar to the reference models, since the MRE was around 3% when the perturbation range was 200% (Fig. 4). S-system models generated by our method can provide accurate simulations within a wide range of the steady-state point. This limitation does not prevent the modelling and analysis of metabolic pathways, as it does with many power-law metabolic models [4, 5].
Robustness against experimental noise is an important requirement for the practical application of modelling methods. Since the Jacobian is rather sensitive to the noise in time series , a robust corrective response to the numerical errors contained in a Jacobian is important in developing a model involving its use. In the method of Diaz-Sierra and Fairén , error correction parameters are incorporated into the S-system model to reduce the effect of experimental noise. However, this approach may lead to an increase in the number of underspecified parameters. As an alternative approach to reducing the experimental noise in time-course data, the estimation of appropriate slopes using a non-linear neural network model is effective , and can provide an error-controlled time course that enables the Jacobian to be obtained with high accuracy. Methods for obtaining accurate estimates of the specific effects of general types of perturbation have been discussed  and might enable more precise analysis of data such as time-scale metabolite concentrations obtained under perturbations.
Mean relative errors (MREs) as a function of experimental errors. The MREs of the S-system models and the original models were measured in case study 2. The time-course data obtained from the models included the perturbation-of-state variable in order to examine the difference in dynamic response between the S-system model and the original Michaelis-Menten model. The Jacobian and steady-state fluxes were reproduced with a 100% numerical error. Numerical errors for the Jacobian were inserted equally into all the elements of the Jacobian. X1was the target of the perturbation. The time-course data were obtained from the S-system model where X1was perturbed by an increase of 50%. Ten time points were sampled for the calculation, with an interval of 0.5 s between them. The MRE was calculated from the time-course data in the S-system model and the original Michaelis-Menten model. In the case of the branched biochemical pathway (case study 2), the Jacobian was increased by 100%, and the three steady-state fluxes, J1–2, J3–5, and J4–6represent the flux through V1 and V2, the flux through V3 and V5 and the flux through V 4 and V6, respectively.
Size of Error (%)
Sorribas and Cascante proposed a method for identifying regulatory patterns using a given set of logarithmic gain measurements . In their paper, they suggested that one strategy for selecting possible patterns is to perform perturbation experiments and to measure the corresponding dynamic response. For practical application of this approach, it is crucial to develop appropriate ways of performing the required experiments; however, measuring the logarithmic gain resulting from various steady-state fluxes is not practical due to a lack of exhaustive measurement method. Our approach can be used to develop reasonably accurate models of metabolic pathways by using a single set of appropriate steady-state flux profiles. Although steady-state flux profile data remains difficult to be measured directly and comprehensively, several methods of measuring steady-state flux profiles by using isotopes have been developed [22, 23]. Our method assumes that the Jacobian obtained is accurate. Therefore it is important to obtain time-course data reflecting transient dynamics after a suitably small perturbation in which the Jacobian behaves in a linear manner .
Comprehensive metabolome data will undoubtedly accumulate as a consequence of advances in metabolic measurement techniques [24–26]. In our laboratory we have developed a high-throughput technique using capillary-electrophoresis mass spectrometry that provides effective time-course data involving a few hundred ionic metabolites [27, 28]. Our method promises to provide high-throughput modelling of large-scale metabolic pathways by exploiting the accumulating metabolome and steady-state flux profile data along with the anticipated developments in metabolome measurement techniques.
Our method provides stable and high-throughput S-system modelling of metabolic pathways because it drastically reduces underspecified parameters by employing the steady-state flux profile and Jacobian retrieved from time-course data. S-system models generated by this method can provide accurate simulations within a wide range around the steady-state point. In combination with the metabolome measurement techniques it should permit high-throughput modelling of large-scale metabolic pathways.
Appendix 1: Biochemical model of yeast galactose metabolism
The rate equations of the model are:
where the rate expressions are:
The parameters used are available in reference . The calculated steady-state conditions were: X1; 0.5 mM (fixed), X2; 0.146 mM, X3; 0.00703 mM, X4; 0.817 mM, X5; 0.243 mM, and the flux through the pathway; 0.0081 mM·s-1.
Appendix 2: Branched biochemical pathway
The rate equations of the branched model the reaction scheme of which is shown in Figure 2 are:
where the rate expressions are:
V = 0.1
We thank Kazunari Kaizu and Katsuyuki Yugi for insightful discussions and providing technical advice. This work was supported in part by a grant from Leading Project for Biosimulation, Keio University, The Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT); a grant from CREST, JST; a grant from New Energy and Industrial Technology Development and Organization (NEDO) of the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry of Japan (Development of a Technological Infrastructure for Industrial Bioprocess Project); and a grant-in-aid from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology for the 21st Century Centre of Excellence (COE) Program (Understanding and Control of Life's Function via Systems Biology).
- Voit EO, Marino S, Lall R: Challenges for the identification of biological systems from in vivo time series data. In Silico Biol. 2005, 5 (2): 83-92.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Savageau MA: Biochemical systems analysis. I. Some mathematical properties of the rate law for the component enzymatic reactions. J Theor Biol. 1969, 25 (3): 365-369.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Savageau MA: Biochemical systems analysis. II. The steady-state solutions for an n-pool system using a power-law approximation. J Theor Biol. 1969, 25 (3): 370-379.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Voit EO, Ferreira AEN: Computational analysis of biochemical systems : a practical guide for biochemists and molecular biologists. 2000, Cambridge ; New York , Cambridge University Press, xii, 531 p.,  p. of plates-Google Scholar
- Torres NV, Voit EO: Pathway analysis and optimization in metabolic engineering. 2002, New York , Cambridge University Press, xiv, 305 p.-View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Savageau MA: Mathematics of organizationally complex systems. Biomed Biochim Acta. 1985, 44 (6): 839-844.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sorribas A, Cascante M: Structure identifiability in metabolic pathways: parameter estimation in models based on the power-law formalism. Biochem J. 1994, 298 ( Pt 2): 303-311.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Voit EO: Models-of-data and models-of-processes in the post-genomic era. Math Biosci. 2002, 180: 263-274. 10.1016/S0025-5564(02)00115-3.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Veflingstad SR, Almeida J, Voit EO: Priming nonlinear searches for pathway identification. Theor Biol Med Model. 2004, 1 (1): 8-10.1186/1742-4682-1-8.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Voit EO, Almeida J: Decoupling dynamical systems for pathway identification from metabolic profiles. Bioinformatics. 2004, 20 (11): 1670-1681. 10.1093/bioinformatics/bth140.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sakamoto E, Iba H: Inferring a system of differential equations for a gene regulatory network by using genetic programming. 2001, 720-726.Google Scholar
- Maki Y, Ueda T, Okamoto M, Uematsu N, Inamura Y, Eguchi Y: Inference of genetic network using the expression profile time course data of mouse P19 cells. 2002, 13: 382-383.Google Scholar
- Kikuchi S, Tominaga D, Arita M, Takahashi K, Tomita M: Dynamic modeling of genetic networks using genetic algorithm and S-system. Bioinformatics. 2003, 19 (5): 643-650. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btg027.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kimura S, Ide K, Kashihara A, Kano M, Hatakeyama M, Masui R, Nakagawa N, Yokoyama S, Kuramitsu S, Konagaya A: Inference of S-system models of genetic networks using a cooperative coevolutionary algorithm. Bioinformatics. 2005, 21 (7): 1154-1163. 10.1093/bioinformatics/bti071.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Maki Y, Tominaga D, Okamoto M, Watanabe S, Eguchi Y: Development of a system for the inference of large scale genetic networks. 2001, 446-458.Google Scholar
- Diaz-Sierra R, Fairen V: Simplified method for the computation of parameters of power-law rate equations from time-series. Math Biosci. 2001, 171 (1): 1-19. 10.1016/S0025-5564(01)00051-7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sorribas A, Lozano JB, Fairen V: Deriving chemical and biochemical model networks from experimental measurements. Recent Res Devel in Physical Chem. 1998, 2: 553-573.Google Scholar
- Diaz-Sierra R, Lozano JB, Fairen V: Deduction of chemical mechanisms from the linear response around steady state. J Phys Chem A. 1999, 103 (3): 337-343. 10.1021/jp983041e.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Savageau MA: Biochemical systems analysis: A study of function and design in molecular biology . 1976, Addison-Wesley Pub. Co.Google Scholar
- de Atauri P, Orrell D, Ramsey S, Bolouri H: Is the regulation of galactose 1-phosphate tuned against gene expression noise?. Biochem J. 2005, 387 (Pt 1): 77-84.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Schmidt H, Cho KH, Jacobsen EW: Identification of small scale biochemical networks based on general type system perturbations. Febs J. 2005, 272 (9): 2141-2151. 10.1111/j.1742-4658.2005.04605.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zhao J, Shimizu K: Metabolic flux analysis of Escherichia coli K12 grown on 13C-labeled acetate and glucose using GC-MS and powerful flux calculation method. J Biotechnol. 2003, 101 (2): 101-117. 10.1016/S0168-1656(02)00316-4.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fischer E, Sauer U: Metabolic flux profiling of Escherichia coli mutants in central carbon metabolism using GC-MS. Eur J Biochem. 2003, 270 (5): 880-891. 10.1046/j.1432-1033.2003.03448.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fiehn O, Kopka J, Dormann P, Altmann T, Trethewey RN, Willmitzer L: Metabolite profiling for plant functional genomics. Nat Biotechnol. 2000, 18 (11): 1157-1161. 10.1038/81137.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ostergaard S, Olsson L, Nielsen J: In vivo dynamics of galactose metabolism in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: metabolic fluxes and metabolite levels. Biotechnol Bioeng. 2001, 73 (5): 412-425. 10.1002/bit.1075.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Neves AR, Ventura R, Mansour N, Shearman C, Gasson MJ, Maycock C, Ramos A, Santos H: Is the glycolytic flux in Lactococcus lactis primarily controlled by the redox charge? Kinetics of NAD(+) and NADH pools determined in vivo by 13C NMR. J Biol Chem. 2002, 277 (31): 28088-28098. 10.1074/jbc.M202573200.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Soga T, Ueno Y, Naraoka H, Matsuda K, Tomita M, Nishioka T: Pressure-assisted capillary electrophoresis electrospray ionization mass spectrometry for analysis of multivalent anions. Anal Chem. 2002, 74 (24): 6224-6229. 10.1021/ac0202684.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sugimoto M, Kikuchi S, Arita M, Soga T, Nishioka T, Tomita M: Large-scale prediction of cationic metabolite identity and migration time in capillary electrophoresis mass spectrometry using artificial neural networks. Anal Chem. 2005, 77 (1): 78-84. 10.1021/ac048950g.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.